I've had a few songs running around in my head lately. Maybe it's the ringing in my ears...
It's rare that I like live versions of songs that have really grabbed me from a studio release. Many bands seem to think that we all crave the improvisational stylings they sometimes bring to popular tunes when performed live. I have a word of advice for any famous musicians/bands/singers that might stop by The Stream: don't.
As with any rule, there is always an exception. And in this case - two. I first heard Shaker Song when I listened to the debut Spyro Gyra album: Spyro Gyra. Did I mention I typically don't like remakes either?
A few years later I happened to catch another of my favorite bands, Manhattan Transfer, singing - you guessed it - Shaker Song. After getting over my initial umbrage (old habits can be hard to break), I decided I loved it! Here's a live version of Shaker Song performed in Japan circa 1986...(takes a moment to load, please e patient)
I love Spyro Gyra's first album. Still have it and still love it!
ReplyDeleteIt is definitely a keeper - what do you think of the Manhattan Transfer version of Shaker Song?
ReplyDeleteX
I like it, too, but not quite as much as the original! The singer is very good though. I really like her voice and she has great stage presence.
ReplyDelete